NHL · Final Recap
Schaefer’s Hat Trick Powers Islanders Past Columbus, 5-1
November 18, 2026 · 2:38 AM
Matthew Schaefer’s three-goal night led New York to a commanding home win over the Blue Jackets.
On Tuesday (Eastern date 2026-11-17; played today) at UBS Arena, the New York Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5-1. Matthew Schaefer supplied the decisive punch with three goals on nine shots, finishing plus-2 with three points and no power-play goals or hits. Anthony Duclair scored once on the power play and added an assist for two points, two shots and a plus-1 rating, with no hits. Tony DeAngelo also recorded a goal and an assist, finishing with two points, two shots, a plus-1 rating and no hits. Zach Werenski scored Columbus’ lone goal on three shots, while Kent Johnson assisted. Cam Talbot made 35 saves on 39 shots for an .897 save percentage, and Ilya Sorokin stopped 27 of 28 for a .964 mark; Columbus had 18 hits to New York’s 14. The Islanders held a 40-29 edge in shots and turned it into a four-goal win.
Key Performers
Matthew Schaefer, NYI: 3 G, 0 A, 3 P, 9 SOG, +2, 0 PPG, 0 hits Anthony Duclair, NYI: 1 G, 1 A, 2 P, 2 SOG, +1, 1 PPG, 0 hits Tony DeAngelo, NYI: 1 G, 1 A, 2 P, 2 SOG, +1, 0 PPG, 0 hits
Standings Impact
The listed standings had New York at 9-6-4 with 22 points and Columbus at 7-11-0 with 14. The Islanders entered on a two-game winning streak; the Blue Jackets were on a four-game skid.
DYMA Insight
New York’s 40-29 shot advantage and Sorokin’s .964 save percentage backed up the gap in DYMA’s Power Index: the Islanders ranked 15th at 65.9, while Columbus stood 26th at 40.7.